The Reedy Point Players have been graced with several awards, acknowledgements, and titles including:

Delaware Theatre
Association Festival

2018

  • Runner Up, Outstanding Production: Jumping
  • Outstanding Achievement in Acting: Aniela Meinhaldt (Jumping)
  • Outstanding Cameo Appearance: Lance Thompson (Jumping)
  • Outstanding Achievement in Playwriting: Brian Smith (Meant to Be)
  • Achievement in Acting: Gail Wagner (Meant to Be)
  • Achievement in Set Design: Reedy Point Players, (Jumping)

2015

  • Outstanding Production: Find Me
  • Outstanding Set Design: Find Me
  • Outstanding Ensemble Performance: Becca Caton, Kathleen Kimber, Gina Olkowski, Kirsten Valania, Sean Wagner, & Matt Furman (Find Me)
  • Best Direction: Gail Wagner (Find Me)
  • Outstanding Performance Actress – Supporting: Becca Caton (Find Me)

2010 – 2014

  • Outstanding Set Design: Angel Kisses in Left Field [2014]
  • Outstanding Ensemble Performance: Kevin Austra & Emily Ciuffetelli, (End of the Movie) [2013]
  • Runner Up Published Works: Forgetful Remembrance [2012]
  • Runner Up Published Works: Off The Grid [2010]

Eastern States Theater Association

  • Outstanding Achievement in Acting: Gail Wagner, Forgetful Remembrance [2012]
  • Outstanding Achievement in Acting: Gail Wagner, Off the Grid [2010]
  • Outstanding Achievement in Sound Design: Marsha Amato Greenspan, Off the Grid [2010]
  • Outstanding Achievement in Costume Design [2010]

Broadway World Delaware

  • Runner Up, Best New Play or Musical: The O’Malley Gambit [2022]
  • Performer of the Decade: Kevin Austra, The Outsiders [2014]
  • Best Actor in a Play (Non-Professional): Kevin Austra, Titanic: Tragedy & Trial [2017]
  • Best Touring Production: The Outsiders [2015]
  • Best Play (Non-Professional): The Outsiders [2014]
  • Best Ensemble in a Play (Non-Professional): The Outsiders [2014]
    Brandon Dawson, Sean Wagner, Kevin Austra, Matthew Furman, Derek Pinchot, Dan Davis, Lauren Bailey, John Bolduc, Max O’Neill, Molly Keifer, Heather Mikles, Rachel Caton, Dave Fullerton, Kevin Swed, Becca Caton, & Sam Vernooy
  • Best Director of a Play (Non-Professional): Erin Miller, The Outsiders [2014]